2024-06-14
Microsoft Delays Recall Release
Last week, Microsoft announced that they are delaying the release of Recall, a feature that takes screenshots every few seconds, which are then stored on users' devices and encrypted. Users can search these screenshots using local AI for future reference. Critics have been outspoken about Recall's privacy implications. The feature was to be launched as a preview in the Copilot+ PCs, which ship on June 18. Recall will now appear as a preview in the Windows Insider Program. Microsoft says, 'We are adjusting the release model for Recall to leverage the expertise of the Windows Insider community to ensure the experience meets our high standards for quality and security.'
Editor's Note
This feature is a great litmus test for thinking 'Security First.' You can easily understand a developer writing such a tool for personal use and someone seeing it and saying 'Cool, that would be a killer feature in Windows!!' A 'What Could Go Wrong' session would quickly lead to not only no way for a Windows feature, but delete that function right now from any developers' machines!! One key reason for killing the feature forever is the scary thought of AI engines ingesting random screen shots of users' screens - Microsoft has already suffered an enormous privacy breach after AI ingested contents of users' hard drives.
John Pescatore
Copilot has multiple forms, app, Edge, Windows, Pro, and 365, and is positioned as a replacement for Cortana, initially branded as Bing Chat, which means you need to not only be conversant on which version is where, but also what they do and if they fit within your security constraints. Specific to Recall, considering the functionality, you need to understand where the snapshots are stored and what is discernable from the local AI. To evaluate Recall, you're going to need to get a Copilot+ PC and install Recall from the Microsoft Insider Program.
Lee Neely
This whole sorry tale has done major damage to Microsoft's reputation regarding putting security before features. The phrase 'closing the barn doors after the horse has bolted' comes to mind.
Brian Honan
I am glad Microsoft is listening to us; however, let's face it, this feature is in preview. It's available to be pulled down and installed. Is there going to be a threat actor that puts two and two together and makes it so that this preview feature is installed for them to use going forward? The problem is not that it's a delayed feature now; the problem is that it's officially part of the system and can be enabled through an update. It's also still not fully secured. They need to pull this until it is properly hardened.
Moses Frost
It is difficult to reconcile this initiative with "Security First."
William Hugh Murray
Read more in
Windows: Update on the Recall preview feature for Copilot+ PCs
The Record: Microsoft shelves Recall feature release after security uproar
SC Magazine: Microsoft's AI Recall feature postponed to address security concerns
Help Net Security: Microsoft delays Windows Recall rollout, more security testing needed
The Hacker News: Microsoft Delays AI-Powered Recall Feature for Copilot+ PCs Amid Security Concerns